| A. Socialization and Related Adult Activities
1. Research Methods
a. Personal Observations
b. Discussions with Research Assistants
c. Canela and Apanyekra Socialization Processes
2. Foci of Socialization
a. Infant Care: by female kin group; “milk siblings”
b. Breast Feeding: on demand; for distraction, given someone’s breast
c. Feeding of Solids: no bottle feeding in 1950s, nothing forced
d. Exploration and Distracting Small Children from Dangers
e. Standing and Walking: babies helped when ready, never forced
f. Weaning: traditionally between 3 and 4 years; now, between teething and walking
(1) Principal weaning technique; tricked into eating, not done against will
(2) Pepper breast only if pregnant; a deplored backland “regular” practice
g. Talking: through imitation and repetition; in joking relationships
h. Urination: no attempt to control it, wet clothing tolerated
i. Defecation: between 2 to 4 years old, when children understand to go outside
(1) Related adult practices; alone, hidden, in the cerrado
(2) Sanitation problems in Sardinha and Escalvado
j. Sex: Important training for tradition of extramarital relations
(1) Penis Play: by mothers and classificatory wives
(2) Masturbation: forbidden; a matter for aunts and uncles to correct
(a) Loss of virginity payments (both sexes); male loss if foreskin loose
(b) Adult modesty; though naked, glans penis and inner genitalia hidden
(3) Opposite-Sex Siblings’ Sex Play: one of two most severely punished offenses
(4) Adolescent or Adult Incest: uterine siblings become crazy and die
(5) Sexual Education of Males: from joking, rafter beds, “spouses,” watching trysts
(a) Homosexuality: rare but tolerated
(b) Males’ first experience with an older classificatory spouse
(6) Sexual Education of Females: from joking uncles, from hearing rafter bed activity
(a) Learns from disciplinary aunt, who also inspects her for broken hymen
(b) Learns by group force if she is not “generous” with her other “husbands”
(c) Learns through being a girl associate, “wife” to a male group
k. Aggression Regulation: external aggression not rewarded for last 150 years
(1) Girls fighting is rare and only when very small
(2) Boys fighting is rare; second worst offense; a trial if blood is drawn
(3) Spirited willfulness of little A?prol; like earlier warrior
(4) War leaders had innate ferocity; externally directed, internal restraint
(5) Non-confrontational at foci, many outlets for frustrations
l. Eating Practices: permissive and irregular for both children and adults
m. Independence/Dependence: girls help parents, boys play in cerrado; of adults
n. Khęętúwayę Festival: pre-pubertal boys cooperate in non-familial group
(1) Boys learn protective roles of kin against unknown and supernatural dangers
(2) Boys confined and visited by uncles who teach traditions and values
o. Ear-piercing for Boys: to listen, understand, and obey
p. Puberty: shift to uncle’s harsher discipline
q. Pepyę Festival: post-pubertal boys learn restrictions
r. Group Disciplinary Practices: to toughen and control adolescents
(1) Uncles as warriors haze nephews for food and sex infractions
(2) Apanyekra practice severe public shaming for sex during Pepyę internment
s. Traditions Lost due to Service Personnel’s Presence: uncle-nephew hazing
(1) Adolescent sex with elderly; youths with menopausal women
(2) Childless women sleeping in the plaza on opposite side from husbands
3. Forces of Socialization
a. Forces of Socialization for Children
(1) Rewarding and Motivating Forces
(a) Parents’ roles; give extra toys and food (Ta?pa); tell stories
(b) Aunts’, uncles’ roles; supply head-baskets and toys; joking, storytelling, hunting
(2) Restraining Forces
(a) Trait formation; not stingy, angry; no fighting, maligning, stealing
(b) Incessant streams of mild talk and insistent requests
(c) Distraction, trick into cooperation; to not confront and weaken will
(d) No verbal abuse used to lessen self-image, unlike backlanders
(e) Fear used to attract attention, impress, and get cooperation
(f) Ignoring the very willful; if control ineffectual, let child have it’s way
(g) Physical punishments; hitting palm of hand for extreme misbehavior
(h) Forcing medicine; acculturative change from late 1950s to 1970s
(i) Aunts and uncles hit only in extreme cases; if ignored return to parents
b. Forces of Socialization for Adolescents
(1) Restraining Forces
(a) Aunts and uncles teach sex restrictions; more detached than parents
(b) Aunts and uncles teach endurance for life roles through confrontation
(c) Attaining strength through maintaining virginity (Pŕŕtsęt)
(d) Uncles send nephews to plaza; impose sex and food restrictions; haze
(e) Formal Friends: fear of “games” against them restrains individuals
(2) Enabling Forces
(a) Food, sex restrictions; “helping hand” to do well in most adult roles
(b) “Medicines,” Formal Friends, cross-sex siblings
(3) Rewarding Forces: public and private awards
(a) For girls
(b) For youths
c. Forces of Socialization for Adults
(1) Rewarding Forces
(a) Extramarital sex partners; general availability helps morale
(b) “Advice” from older relatives; inter-generational adult bonding
(c) Appointment of children to positions of honor brings honor to their parents
(d) Prestigious roles; few positions for highest roles, some high roles for all
(2) Enabling Forces
(a) Food and sex restrictions against pollutions by shamans and hunters
(b) Formal Friends, the most developed helping device for adults
(c) “Powers” from ghosts, hunting “vision” from “medicines”
(d) Orders for carrying out most roles is strongly felt need
(3) Restraining Forces for Adults
(a) Shame; enculturated inhibiting factor; hŕmren have much shame, Clowns have little shame
(b) Formal Friend “games”; shaming acts replacing uncles’ discipline
(c) Stories as warnings; she hung herself to avoid marrying mother’s choice
(d) Concern about reputation of stinginess (hőőtsč); lose sex partners
(e) Apprehension of negative rumors (tswa?nă); spoiled name
(f) Age-set admonitions; pressure on men; noncompliance is antisocial
(g) Political pressure; no enforcement agent, but deep need felt to comply
(h) Fear of shaman’s spell; enforced generosity traditionally, but now weak
(i) Folk Catholic Satan; when God is not “looking,” Satan harms strayers
(j) Spurning by “other spouses”; open sex talk and rumors diminishing
4. Ethnotheories of Individual Development
a. Personality Is Imminent: so training is permissive
b. Discipline Breeds Respect: so train with strength
c. Conceptualization of Growth Periods: steps slanting upward
5. Summary
a. Permissive Training: generates low tolerance of frustration
b. Dependency Training: creates expectation of being cared for by others
c. Discipline and Freedom: control at puberty contrasted with sexual freedom later
d. Acculturative Factors in the Disorganization of the 1970s
e. State of Being in the 1970s: strong desires with little control
B. Psychological “Polarities,” Values, and Behavioral Orientations
1. Valued Orientations: complementary and oppositional “pairings”
a. Generosity versus Stinginess
(1) Backlanders “stingy” with year’s subsistence stores
(2) Game eaten secretly to avoid “begging”; “generous” when confronted
(3) Individuals gave to avoid accusations of witchcraft, a pervasive fear
(4) Rights to sex and other services belong to desirer; result in bold “begging”
b. Feeling and Caring versus Self-Centeredness
(1) Disapproval of backlanders’ lack of strong caring for others
(2) Feelings over fairness in distributions of goods; trading difficulties
(3) Telling the truth less important than not hurting feelings; “lying”
c. Joy and Fun versus Sadness and Introspection
(1) Joking relationships enliven life; opposite sexes, sexual references
(2) Expressing joy when Formal Friends honored; comic relief of festivals
(3) Introspection considered evil; sad individuals must join the group
(4) Activity, noise, and movement almost necessary; group action best
d. Individuality within Solidarity
(1) High group involvement does not eliminate individuality which is respected
(2) Extreme individual tendencies accepted and ignored once established
(3) Initiative within “shame”; Wetheads (hŕmren) join Dryheads (Clowns)
e. Endurance versus Weakness
(1) Male endurance in work and forbearance in marriage valued; women direct
(2) Women express feelings more; softer, less patient (men’s view)
(3) Admiration for permanence and durability; stones, armadillo, a haakhat
f. The Beautiful and the Ugly
(1) Straight roads and hair, open and distant vistas, straight posture
(2) Tolerance for variant individuals (Moon’s descendants); city returnee
(3) Individuals conceal or ignore body defects; no pity sought
(4) Dignity and poise even while “begging”; Apanyekra more direct
g. The Little Good and the Little Bad
(1) Pretentiousness is second greatest evil
(2) Physical deformities as little evils; no bad naming or extremes
(3) Clowns seen as only somewhat bad; Tŕmhŕk, Pepkahŕk, Më?khęn compared
(4) Paired complementarity and paired opposition; moderate-extreme ranges
h. Avoidance versus Conflict
(1) In politics, absence preferred to confrontation (cases of two chiefs)
(2) Ceremonialism; battle ceremonially prevented by intervening file of honor
(3) Terminological avoidance affines, Formal Friends; no hostility spoken
(4) Through diversion, expressionless faces, falsifying, nonappearance
i. Youth versus Age
(1) Kuwrč’s death, extreme mourning for ideal young woman; festival postponed
(2) Festival roles largely for the young; girl associates, initiates
(3) Secular dancing and marriage; hearth group maintained for the young
j. Kin before Affines: harmony versus tension
k. Following Orders versus Individual Initiative
(1) Killing backlander cattle on orders of any other Canela
(2) Order issuers; chiefs, Pró-khămmă, household heads, kay
(3) Individual Authority; orders from God
l. Inner or Outer, We or They
(1) Dualistic forms in the language; special pronoun, inclusive-exclusive
(2) Dualism between groups, concepts, items; oppositions made “similar”
2. Observations: assistants work better with polarities; need to resolve conflict
C. Socioceremonial Units: moieties, high and low honor, ritual matriliny
1. Defining the Units: in daily life as well as ceremonial
2. Recruitment Principles
3. Age-Set Moieties: Upper versus Lower; recruited by relative age
a. Formation of Age-Sets: through initiation festivals over a 10-year period
b. Pró-khămmă Age-Set: governs council of elders for 20 years
c. Separate Age-Set Activities: loss of traditional age-set names
(1) Political disintegration when Indian service hired age-set leaders
(2) Possible origin of age-sets; Pepyę warriors
d. Moieties compete as Work Forces: for agriculture and road building
e. Roles of Age-Set Moieties in Festivals: the most frequently used organizing principle for groups
f. Recruitment of Women: appointed by Pró-khămmă; wet-headed in status
g. Eastern Timbira Comparisons of Krahó and Krĩkatí
h. Behavior Within and Outside the Festival Context
4. Red and Black Regeneration (“Rainy”) Season Moieties
a. “Regeneration” Defined: Red/Black oscillation; “outer” clarified
b. Recruitment into Regeneration Moieties: only case of female name-sets
c. Principal Characteristics of Moieties: meet at plaza’s edge; competitive teams for log racing
(1) Alternate Ascendancy Status of Moieties: leveling; logs’ shape, “growth”
(2) Ayrën Ceremony: intermoiety extramarital sex exchanged for meat
d. Diminution of the Regeneration Moiety System: sharecropping for backlanders a factor in system’s loss
5. Plaza Group Moieties
a. Definitions of Plaza Groups: three vs. three in plaza’s center; symmetrical, opposed
b. Characteristics of Plaza Groups in the Fish, Khęętúwayę, and Pepyę Festivals
c. Recruitment of Girl Associates: appointed by Pró-khămmă, by group choice
d. Evolving Position of Plaza Group Moieties: these earlier elements may be “inserts” in age-set acts
6. Men’s Societies: by name-set transmission
a. Men’s Societies Compared with Plaza Groups: two vs. one at plaza’s edge; asymmetrical
b. Recruitment of Girl Associates: varies between Pró-kkămmă, membership, uncles’ veto
c. Comparison with the Krahó Men’s Societies: both tribes losing name affiliation
7. “Wetheads” and “Dryheads”: by name-set or by Pró-khămmă appointment
a. Visiting Chiefs: Tŕmhŕk (King Vultures) have high ceremonial honor
(1) Traditional and modified patriline succession (F/S, %/BS, %/”B”S)
(2) Procession to plaza; Pepkahŕk; high honor
b. Clown Society: low ceremonial honor, little restraint through “shame”
(1) Recruitment by group choice
(2) Girl associates; the lowest status; their act epitomizes greatest “evils”
8. Ritual Societies: river-oriented
a. Festival Haakhat: by matriliny, name-transmission or both
b. Lodge and Haakhat Compared: location, ownership, Pró-khămmă appointed
c. Acculturation: from matriliny to naming because easier, less confining
d. Individual and Family Recruitment: varies with ritual
9. Relative Status of Women in the Various Socioceremonial Units
10. Hypothetical Development through the Eras of Organizing Principles
a. Early Period and Regeneration Principle
b. Riverine Period and the Haakhat Principle
c. Bellicose Period and the Age-Set Principle: wars, visiting chiefs, hŕmren honor,”patrilines”
11. Summary and Discussion of Canela Socioceremonial Units
D. Political System: chieftainship, council of elders, judicial system
1. The Chieftainship: one or several chiefs, serve different purposes
a. Evidence for Stronger Earlier Leadership: language, orders, obedience
(1) Inferences of authority from “broad” term, “hear-know-obey-perform”
(2) Compulsion to follow commands is notably pervasive
(3) Reported great discipline, dispatch, rectitude, conformity of ancients
b. Choice of Tribal Leader by Outsiders
c. Roles of First Chief: he takes political initiatives, their extent varies
(1) Head of Council of Elders: leads morning planning, makes individual assignments
(a) Conducts plaza meetings; provides topics, listens, declares consensus
(b) Supervises plaza decisions; sacred nature, no anger, no enforcement
(c) Allows alternative leaders; deputy chiefs, Pró-khămmă, other elders
(d) Plans day of work and hunting groups, women, family tasks, messengers
(2) Age-Set Moiety Leader: leads work group versus other moiety; provides lunches
(3) Tribal Representative: to Indian service, visitors, and backlanders
(a) Three kinds of civilizados, backland, Barra do Corda, big-city people
(b) Other Eastern Timbira visitors, Krahó, Krĩkatí, Pukobyé
(c) Apanyekra receive far more visits from other Timbira than Canela
(4) Chief Justice: hearings; his style, payments, no enforcement
d. Chiefs as Shamans: not main power source but some compliance from fear
e. Range of Powers: moves into power vacuums; balanced by Pró-khămmă
f. Other Political Leaders: first chief’s deputies and also his rivals
(1) Deputy Chiefs: appointed by first chief as help, are not his rivals
(2) Self-appointed Leaders: all are former initiation festival officials
(3) Indian Service Appointments: formerly the custom but a rare act today
g. Schisms: when potential leaders try to establish a new village site
(1) Succession to Chieftainship, 1951–1957: Kaarŕ?khre’s “commission”
(a) Founding a separate village; from farm huts to Indian service support
(b) Intervillage rivalry when rumors not settled daily by councils
(c) Inability to verbalize competition for leadership; betrayal of peace
(2) Separatist Movements, 1963–1968: five potential chiefs, five villages
(3) Reunification, 1968: put on initiation festival to involve most children
h. Succession: to kin or able man; council and outside “authorities” help
i. Chiefly Characteristics: masterful but not overbearing
(1) Kinds of leaders; age-set commandant, file leader, warrior, sing-master
(2) Not hŕmren in state, political, not ceremonial; two routes to power
(3) No personality cult, not to appear “greater than others”; salary helps
(4) Tyranny impossible; tactics spontaneous, partly unconscious, secretive
j. Bases of Political Power
2. Council of Elders: older males meeting in plaza
a. Meetings: sequence of events, morning planning, age-set’s positions
(1) Informal topics, game killed, backland evils, neutralization of rumors
(2) Formal part, ancient formal speech, order of speakers, termination call
b. Pró-khămmă Age-Set: dominates council of elders (average age: 45–65)
(1) Its formation through four initiation festivals during 10 years
(2) Place in council of elders; relationships among the three age-sets
(3) Sequence over four decades (1950s-1980s); three Pró-khămmă age-sets
(4) Change proceeds in steps, not at even rate, due to 20-year cycle
(5) Ascendancy over Upper age-set moiety; contrast with four other moieties
(6) Formal leader, commandant of novices in final Pepyę, if he survives
(7) Apanyekra elders; age-set formation and symmetry
c. Roles of the Pró-khămmă Age-Set: apart from those of the council of elders
(1) Govern Festivals, Rituals, and Other Ceremonies
(a) Initiate, give permission, or order ceremonies to be performed
(b) Choose performers; designate new succession lines; direct performances
(c) Debate and determine sequence of events
(2) Bestow Honor Awards to Youths: for their good performance in festivals
(3) Accept Honor Meat Pies: from hŕmren persons returning to social activity
(4) Receive First Crops: designate some hŕmren to test them for ripeness
d. Roles of the Council of Elders
(1) Representation of everyone in tribe by “uncles” or “grandfathers”
(a) Inter-familial problems surface first in plaza, discussed by uncles
(b) Rumors resolved in plaza
(2) Check on power of chief through informal interplay in daily meetings
(a) Chief resigned because denounced by a Pró-khămmă in the early 1980s
(b) Four new chiefs installed in several years
e. Council as Key to Solidarity: reliance on meetings unusual
3. Judicial System
a. General Characteristics: hearings between extended families
b. Typical Hearing: uncles lead, testimony sought, frustration aired
c. Characteristic Problems: any disturbance; mostly marital, then theft
(1) In Marriage: virginity loss; retaining husband; divorce; shamed spouse
(2) Theft: beads, iron tools, household utensils, ceremonial artifacts
(3) Physical Abuse: minimal with exceptions for drunkenness; stingy girl
(4) Violence: not characteristic; acculturative increase; urbanized Canela
(5) Suspicion of Witchcraft: 1903 case; rapidity of resolution in 1970s
d. Three Levels of Hearings: among elders; between families; by chief
e. Principles Used at Hearings
(1) Maintain Peace: fear that categorization into social parts may be divisive
(2) Consensus: the Canela Genius, a problem with research assistant groups
(3) Compromise and Social Leveling: done by the more prestigious
(a) A Trial: peace before justice
(b) Overlook thefts to keep peace, due to ceremonial and political roles
(4) Ease Shame, Save Face: offense remembered (shame); folk Catholic guilt
(5) Restitution, Not Punishment: punitive payments are unusual
(a) Restitution of marital payments depends on extent of steps in marriage
(b) Punitive payments for “leaving children”; loss of all material goods by man
f. Effect of Judicial System: frustration reduction leads to satisfaction and low emigration
E. Terminological Relationship Systems: kinship and domestic units
1. The Nine Relationship Systems
2. Consanguineal Terminological System: Crow-like kindreds, “parallel transmission”
a. Terms FZ = FZD = FZDD = FZDDD = FM = MM; MB = MF = FF = FMB; F = FZS = FZDS = FZDDS
b. Distinction between One-Link-Away and Further-Links-Away Kin: “Restrictions” kin
c. Distinctive Crow-III Kintypes: further-link terminological exceptions
d. Successions D/M, male DH/WF, ZS/MB, “Z”S/M “B,” S/F: taking their place
e. Demographic Arrangements in Relation to Village Circle and Farms
(1) The “Hearth”: female kin with families are smallest economic unit
(a) Elementary family, the eating together unit
(b) Hearth unit splits, oldest daughters build new house beside or behind mother’s
(2) Parallel-Cousin Matrilateral Arc: “mothers’ longhouse”
(a) Examples of the Canela and Apanyekra longhouse
(b) Comparison of economic, jural, ritual, and exogamic domestic units
(c)Village and farm unit arrangements; male as well as female factors
(3) Cross-Cousin, Across-the-Plaza Kin: “grandmothers’ longhouses”
(a) Crow-III patterns broken through naming, Formal and Informal Friendships, co-fatherships
(b) Hypothetically broken less in earlier times of higher populations
3. Affinal Terminological System
a. Distinctions and Usages
(1) “In-House/Out-of-House” Distinctions: born-in/married-into
(2) Same-Sex Same-Generation Relationships: male Z over male W and female B over female H
(3) Same-Sex Adjacent-Generation Authority Distinctions: senior/junior
(4) Opposite-Sex Adjacent-Generation Avoidance Terms: meanings, behavior
(5) Avoidance Terms as Alternatives to Spouse Terms: three links away
(a) In “parallel transmission”
(b) Name-set transmission, choice based in alternative behavior
(c)Across-the-plaza matrilines; wife’s “aunts”/”nieces”
(6) Opposite-Sex Same-Generation Affines: spouses and “other spouses”
(a) Not “potential” spouses; “other” spouses more appropriate
(b) Sororate, a sister or close “sister” preferred for child care
(c) Joking relationship; much joy in life comes from such play
(7) Secondary Consanguineal Terms
b. Comments on the Affinal System
c. Honorific Pronoun Yę: for some affines and Formal Friends
4. Name-Set Transmission Terminology: female F “Z”/female “B”D, male M “B”/male “Z”S
a. Special Terms: i-túwa-re (my-young-one) is used for both sexes
b. The Informal Agreement between “Sisters” and “Brothers”
c Distant Siblingships: maintained by name exchange or broken by incest
d. Earlier Exchanges with More Distant “Siblings”
e. Creation of New Names: from name-giver’s life experiences
f. Name-Sets, Name-Givers and Name-Receivers, and Festival Roles
g. Name Changes during a Pŕlrŕ Log Racing Ceremony
5. Formal Friendship Terminology: same-sex or opposite-sex bonds of solidarity
a. Extensive Systems of Reference and Their Honorific Pronoun Yę
b. Initiation of Formal Friendships: Ntęę ceremony; two novices bathe; paired girl associates; linked names
6. Informal Friendship Terminology: between two men of the same age-set; dual pronoun reference
7. Mortuary Terms: consanguines and affines
8. Teknonymy: consistent address
a. Between Cross-Sex Siblings: name-receiver’s parent
b. Spouses and “Spouses” in Long-term Affairs: first born’s parent
9. Contributing-Father Terminology: no unique terms but affects behavior
10. Ceremonial Relationship Terminology: no unique terms, sometimes uses consanguinal terms
F. Marriage: to any non-kin, steps into marriage, payments, ethno-ideology
1. Preferences and Restrictions: no alliances; sororate; longhouse exogamy
2. Classificatory Spouses: intertribal opposite-sex unrelatedness
3. Incestuous Marriage: kinship distances; penalties
4. Steps into Marriage: bind the couple increasingly closer
a. Engagement: earlier times, girl 4–6, boy 12–18; usually broken
b. Marriage Definition: losses of virginity, widowhood, singleness
(1) Detachable men, those without children through marriage
(2) Single women with children (më mpíyapit) respected
c. Marital Hearings: “contracting” and “adjusting” the marriage
(1) Large payment for youth to leave; virginity and first marriage valued
(2) Other sequences; acculturation; virginity stolen, then “adjusted”
d. Purchase of Son-in-Law: between extended families; now exchange
e. Painting the Daughter-in-Law’s Belt: gives her sexual freedom and further secures marriage
(1) Sufficiently accepted by in-laws to participate openly in sanctioned extramarital relations
(2) Period of woman’s great freedom before pregnancy and child raising
(a) Earlier era, women slept with men in plaza
(b) Modern times, uncles have lost control of youths, so sons-in-law complain of wife’s activities
f. Presentation of Mother-in-Law’s Meat Pie: acknowledgment of wife’s sexual freedom
g. Conception: catches her husband until their children are grown
h. Childbirth: basic marriage-securing step, if the baby lives
i. Couvade: cements marriage, domesticates husband; isolates mother and baby
j. Postpartum Co-Father Meat Pie Rite: final payment for husband
5. Marital Payments and Balance of Costs
a. Gifts versus Payments for Sexual Services
b. Contributions by Husband and Wife to the Marriage
6. Purpose of Payments: to keep men married; the shame of public hearings
7. Purpose of Marriage: to provide a “hearth” group for raising children
8. Lovemaking and Affairs: sanctioned by festival arrangements
a. Informal Relationships: long affairs, quick encounters, life’s zest
b. Women Also Take the Initiative: beginning of embraced Western dancing style
9. Divorce: “none” while children are growing; 7 divorces in 96 marriages studied
a. Starting a Trend in the 1970s
b. Divorce among the Eastern Timbira: less frequent among the Canela
10. Group Age-Set Marriage: in earlier times each youth led to wife
11. Ethno-ideology: social structure built on “blood” linkages
a. “Blood” Concept: first-link kin pollution; spouses assume restrictions of one-linkers but do not become blood kin
b. Flow of Humanity: matrilines pass on linearly, husbands attached
c. Extending the Sweet Potato Vine: marriage enables “descent”
d. Across-the-Plaza Bridges of “Blood”: marriages connect matrilines
e. Cross-Cousin and Parallel-Cousin Longhouse Matrilines
12. Summary of Village “Blood” Ethnostructure: of kinship and marriage |